In the busy town of Irvington, NJ, sits a pizza place that holds the name of New York’s glorious borough: Brooklyn Pizza. The pizzeria has become quite a controversial topic among locals. I won’t be speaking much on that but what I will do is dive into what you get when you visit Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington, NJ.
Is it everything some Irvington residents have been waiting for, or is it an establishment that still needs work? We’ll find that out by looking at customer reviews, personal experiences, and pizza analytics to give you an in-depth look at what Brooklyn Pizza really has to offer. Let’s set the scene first.
A Slice of Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington, NJ
As soon as you step inside Brooklyn Pizza, the smells only a real pizzeria can boast hit you with melted cheese, toasted dough, and the rich tangy smell of tomato sauce. Copying the casual feel of a New York City pizzeria, this eatery aims to let its customers experience something authentic. Not too fancy to be intimidating and not too bare to be unwelcoming. The walls are covered in pictures and memorabilia that scream Brooklyn but don’t cross over into cheesy territory.
Hearing chatter, laughter, and sometimes a sizzle or ding that lets you know there’s fresh pizza ready amplifies the ambiance even more. The setting is comfortable enough for those who want to quickly get food during their lunch break or enjoy a relaxed meal at night, but also gives off the busy energy that New York City is famous for. But any pizzeria can have good vibes. The true test comes on what they have on their menu next.
Feature Category | What I have to say |
|---|---|
Unique Selling Points | Authentic Italian-American cuisine. High-quality, locally sourced ingredients. |
Menu Variety | Wide range of pizzas. Italian-American classics like pasta and sandwiches. Specialty dishes like spaghetti carbonara and eggplant parmigiana. |
Ambiance | Warm, inviting atmosphere. Family-friendly setting. |
Customer Service | Friendly, accommodating staff. Focus on customer satisfaction. |
Community Involvement | Active participation in local events. Promotions and deals for locals. |
Accessibility and Convenience | Easily accessible location in Irvington, NJ. Ample parking availability. Dine-in, takeout, and delivery options. Efficient ordering process (in-person, phone, online). |
Digital Engagement | Vibrant online presence. Active social media engagement. Regular updates on offerings and events. |
Must Try Delicacies at Brooklyn Pizza
Dish | What's in it | Comments |
|---|---|---|
Chicken Alfredo with Broccoli Pizza | Chicken, Alfredo sauce, broccoli, and cheese | Highly recommended, not overwhelming, and delicious |
Greek Salad with Shrimp or Chicken | Lettuce, tomatoes, cucumbers, olives, feta cheese, Greek dressing, and choice of shrimp or chicken | The best among their salads, a must-try for salad lovers |
Turkey Ham and Pineapple Pizza | Turkey ham, pineapple, and cheese | A unique and delightful combination, worth trying |
Italian Cheese Burger | Cheeseburger with Italian-inspired toppings | Despite some issues, a popular item to taste |
Spaghetti and Meat Sauce | Spaghetti noodles with meat sauce | Amazing and generously portioned pasta dish |
Ratings
Aspect | Why I gave these ratings |
|---|---|
Ambience | Limited seating and crowded standing area. |
Food Quality | Delicious pizza and salads, but occasional quality issues. |
Taste | I loved the taste of their food and its freshness. |
Customer Service | Good service, but delayed service in peak hours |
Staff Behavior | Some staff are rude, and some are friendly |
Cleanliness | Average cleanliness, I noted occasional issues. |
Parking | Limited parking options, often crowded in peak hours |
Menu Options | Varied menu with different options. |
Pricing Options | Affordable and the prices are justified. |
Pros and Cons of Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington NJ
Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
Authentic Italian-American Cuisine | Limited cuisine variety beyond Italian-American staples. |
Strong Community Engagement | Potential for busy periods leading to longer wait times. |
Eco-Friendly and Sustainable Practices | May be more expensive than standard fast-food pizza options. |
High-Quality, Locally Sourced Ingredients | Limited delivery area compared to larger chains. |
Customizable Catering and Event Services | Space constraints for hosting large events on-site. |
Robust Online Presence and Social Media Engagement | Reliance on digital platforms may alienate non-tech-savvy customers. |
Delicious chicken Alfredo | Raw onions and green peppers in some dishes |
Welcoming Ambiance and Family-Friendly Setting | Parking availability might be challenging during peak hours. |
What Sets Brooklyn Pizza Apart in Irvington?
Irvington’s Brooklyn Pizza is a unique restaurant. It has always been famous for its genuine New York-style pizza. What sets Brooklyn Pizza apart from all the rest? They use first-rate products; for instance, their slices are made from San Marzano tomatoes and imported Italian flour.
After that, it is baked in an oven made of bricks which soars above 700 degrees. This ensures that each slice is crispy on one side while the cheese inside melts to perfection. If you ask around, you will hear others say that the sauce is just right. More so than this, it has numerous toppings and is flavor-packed.
You will definitely appreciate all the pepperoni, sausage, or mushrooms added to your pizza! Looking at its interiors, one can see that it has a lively atmosphere about it. Also, there is a huge print on one of the walls with huge letters saying brick oven pie and Frank Sinatra songs on replay behind the counter. Usually, groups of friends as well as families gather here to have dinner together.
Menu Dive: What's Authentic About Brooklyn Pizza?
The thin yet sturdy crust that allows for the perfect fold isn’t an easy thing to follow when it comes to New York-style pizza. But placing their pies as an homage to these celebrated characteristics is what Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington, NJ, does. With a crispy bottom and slightly chewy rim, many customers have said that with every bite they get a satisfying ‘crunch’ that is usually missing from other places close by.
The variety of pizzas they offer is wide enough to cater to any taste. People who only like cheese and purists alike can find something to eat here. Customer favorites include the classic Margherita, the meat lover’s special, and more creative options like their chicken Alfredo that gets praised for hitting that comfort food spot.
It isn’t just the selection that deserves praise, it’s also how big the slices are. Just like any place in New York City, Brooklyn Pizza serves large portions which is good for us but as all large slice lovers know only if they’re fresh and tasty to a department where Brooklyn Pizza seems to always excel according to customer reviews.
Beyond Pizza – A Peek at Additional Offerings
Brooklyn Pizza, a name that even Italian-American cuisine enthusiasts are familiar with, has gone beyond being just a pizza joint. They’ve curated a menu filled with classic Italian-American dishes that will satisfy anyone’s appetite. The menu caters to all preferences and cravings so if you’re not feeling pizza on your visit make sure to explore everything else they have!
One thing that stands out at Brooklyn Pizza is their selection of hot sandwiches. These are not just your plain old sandwiches, these are oozy meaty, cheesy and perfectly toasted bread kind of sandwiches. The type to make you go “mm” after every bite. Which is why we’ve labeled them as ‘different’ but ‘comforting’.
If you’re a pasta lover, then this is the place for you. Their lasagna dish will have your mouth watering even from just reading the description alone. They have layers upon layers of pasta, cheese, and sauce that they bake to perfection each time. On the other hand, their chicken Alfredo is a fan favorite and it’s easy to see why, they make sure their chicken is always tender and their pasta cooked perfectly.
Calzones are also something they offer at Brooklyn Pizza that customers rave about, “delish” could be an understatement here but don’t worry, their dough quality sets all of their pizzas apart from other places too! Many people claim these calzones will fix any Italian-American food craving you might have and we vouch for them too.
But Brooklyn Pizza isn’t just pizza! It goes beyond pizza which brings us back to our main point: This establishment is more than a pizza place; it’s a culinary destination for anyone looking to treat themselves to some Italian-American cuisine.
Now let’s talk about dining experience:
The Ambiance and Setting
The moment you walk into Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington NJ, you will feel like you walked into Italy itself. It has such a warm feeling that makes it so inviting as soon as you step inside, making it perfect for families or friends who want good food with lasting memories.
Customer Service & Hospitality
Customers are valued here at Brooklyn Pizza and it shows with the staff always being super friendly no matter what day or time it may be.. The goal isn’t only to satisfy clients but to make them so happy they’re coming back. Ordering from Brooklyn Pizza, Irvington.
Upon hearing about their question “Why go anywhere else for pizza?” I was really curious and let me tell you now I understand why. You don’t have to only eat at the restaurant, there are other dining options too such as takeout and delivery. In a rush? No problem, grab a slice on the go! Their menus are created to cater to the three different types of dining options they offer.
Online Presence & Social Media
Living in such a digital age now, having great online presence and social media engagement is a must. They know this, which is why they’ve built an amazing one. With them you’ll never miss out on any new offers or events.
The Best Slice - Parsing Through Taste
As much as we hate to admit it, there will always be at least one unhappy customer out there especially when it comes to food. With thousands of different opinions on pizza itself, that creates thousands of mixed reviews for Brooklyn Pizza.
The eatery’s cheese is always touted as “so fresh” and “so stretchy,” and its sauce is described as striking a perfect balance not too sweet, but also not too acidic. That’s important to customers who don’t want their two favorite pizza ingredients to ruin their pie.
Customers said they also return because of the consistent taste and quality. In 2019, some of them told The Diamondback that Brooklyn Pizza made it onto their list of local favorites for just those reasons.
However, negative reviews still carried some common themes. One recent review posted on a viral Twitter thread said the dough “smelled like dirty mop water.” While this might be an outlier, it still says something to those who want a safe meal.
Some reviewers were disappointed by a few rogue raw onions and green peppers on top of their pies; others were equally upset about getting “burnt” or “cold” ones. But these all sound more manageable than getting a whiff of dirty mop water while you try to enjoy your meal.
All in all, rushing through orders is never easy in a fast-paced kitchen. Though, if Brooklyn Pizza wants to continually have reviews that rave above any other pizza place, these little hiccups will need some care sooner rather than later.
Friendly Faces or a Fast-Paced Frenzy? Staff Interactions
The way staff treat customers can make or break a business. For Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington, NJ, my experience could go either way. With some praising the friendly demeanor of the staff and saying that they were drawn to it, it’s hard to say if other locals feel the same way. In this line of work at a busy pizza place it seems like efficiency is key.
But there are two sides to every story. Some patrons aren’t as happy about their experience and report feeling ignored by an overwhelmed and rushed staff. One person even said that the workers’ behavior was unprofessional and that he didn’t have a good time thanks to them. It seems like people are able to order efficiently, but they don’t get back the same energy from the employees.
Misunderstandings over orders are not uncommon in busy pizza places. But one person took notice that while mistakes can happen, how they’re fixed is crucial. They felt like their problem wasn’t taken seriously, while others were happy with customer service after someone messed up their order.
Pricing at Brooklyn Pizza – Worth It?
The way pricing works can often determine whether you’ll ever come back or not. In this case, it looks like Brooklyn’s cost-to-quality ratio isn’t holding up too well against its competitors. People want to know if their money is going towards a quality slice.
When it comes to how much you’re actually getting for what you paid for, people seem to be on board with Brooklyn’s pricing. Many customers praised how big each slice is and how it makes them feel like they got more than what they paid for.
Quality-wise though, opinions vary greatly. While some think that taste alone justifies spending a few extra dollars on a slice here instead of somewhere else down the street others don’t think so at all. Comparing value pizzas between different places, a few bucks might not be a deal breaker for some.
But others might think that it is. A slice from here looks like it costs more than all the other places and while that was okay for some customers, others felt like the difference in price didn’t match the difference in taste.
Pricing at Brooklyn Pizza – Worth the Dough?
The way pricing works can often determine whether you’ll ever come back or not. In this case, it looks like Brooklyn’s cost-to-quality ratio isn’t holding up too well against its competitors’. People want to know if their money is going towards a quality slice.
When it comes to how much you’re actually getting for what you paid for, people seem to be on board with Brooklyn’s pricing. Many customers praised how big each slice is and how it makes them feel like they got more than what they paid for.
Quality-wise though, opinions vary greatly. While some think that taste alone justifies spending a few extra dollars on a slice here instead of somewhere else down the street others don’t think so at all. Comparing value pizzas between different places, a few bucks might not be a deal breaker for some.
But others might think that it is. A slice from here looks like it costs more than all the other places and while that was okay for some customers, others felt like the difference in price didn’t match the difference in taste.
Brooklyn Pizza’s Community Involvement in Irvington
Events and Sponsors
The Brooklyn Pizza in Irvington, NJ isn’t just your regular pizza place; it’s a lively part of the community. They actively participate in local events and often sponsor school functions, charity events, and local sports teams. This not only strengthens the bond between their customers but also shows their commitment to giving back to the town that supports them.
Promos and Deals
Understanding how important it is to show support, Brooklyn Pizza offers various promotions and special deals to Irvington residents. From discounted family meals to special offers for local events, this pizzeria makes sure that everyone knows they exist.
Ordering from Brooklyn Pizza, Irvington
Dine-in Options, or Takeout?
This place lets you choose what you want. Customers can eat inside the restaurant if they wish or can opt for takeout instead. You can even have your pizza delivered. They accept orders over the phone and on their website as well as through popular food delivery apps. This delivery service covers all of Irvington!
Online Presence and Social Media
The people behind Brooklyn Pizza know how to keep up with current trends. Their website is easy to navigate, allowing customers to look at the menu, order food, or check out upcoming deals — which are posted regularly on their social media platforms where they also interact with their customers.
Sustainability and Environmental Commitment
Eco-Friendly Practices
Not only does Brooklyn Pizza use biodegradable packaging but they’ve also cut down on waste wherever possible. It’s clear that these people aren’t just here to serve amazing food but also do their part in preserving the environment.
Supporting Local Suppliers
Thanks to them using locally sourced ingredients from local farmers and suppliers, this shop ensures that everything they make is always fresh and high quality. Not only that but this act of supporting local businesses creates a cycle of support within Irvington.
Special Events and Catering Services
Use of the Cozy Space
You can use Brooklyn Pizza for private parties and events. They even offer menus that are customizable based on your event, making sure that everyone has a great time eating with them.
Catering Services
If you’re having an event at another location, don’t worry. Brooklyn Pizza will still be able to provide their food there. Whether it’s a family gathering, corporate business event, or community function they’ve got you covered. Just work with their team to get the menu you want.
Wrapping Up!
Brooklyn Pizza is the heart of Irvington. It isn’t your average pizza place, it’s a family. And they serve real Brooklyn-style pizza, not the fake stuff you see elsewhere. What makes this place special is the food and atmosphere combined.
It’s hard to explain why Brooklyn Pizza is so popular. Maybe it’s the delicious food? Or maybe it’s how comfortable their restaurant feels? Or perhaps it’s because of how much they give back to their community. But one thing’s for sure, they stand out from the rest.
They’re eco-friendly, reliable with their services, and even take extra precautions for health safety. So in short you’re getting more than just pizza here, you’re getting an experience unlike any other.
